Does Turkey Hill Coffee Ice Cream Have Caffeine? The Complete Answer

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This post may contain affiliate links, meaning I may receive a commission if you purchase using these links.

Estimated reading time: 2 minutes

If you’re wondering whether Turkey Hill Coffee Ice Cream contains caffeine, you’re not alone. Many ice cream lovers want to know if their favorite frozen dessert will keep them awake at night. Here’s everything you need to know about caffeine content in Turkey Hill’s popular coffee-flavored ice creams, specifically addressing the question: Does Turkey Hill Coffee Ice Cream Have Caffeine?

The Short Answer: Yes, Turkey Hill Coffee Ice Cream Contains Caffeine

So, Does Turkey Hill Coffee Ice Cream Have Caffeine? Yes, it does, but in mild amounts.

Turkey Hill Colombian Coffee ice cream does contain caffeine, though in relatively small amounts compared to a cup of coffee. The caffeine comes from real coffee extract and Colombian coffee beans used in the premium ice cream recipe.

How Much Caffeine Is in Turkey Hill Coffee Ice Cream?

A typical serving of food (½ cup) of Turkey Hill Colombian Coffee ice cream contains approximately 5-10 milligrams of caffeine. To put this in perspective:

  • Turkey Hill Coffee Ice Cream: 5-10mg per ½ cup
  • Regular Coffee: 95mg per 8 oz cup
  • Iced Coffee: 165mg per 16 oz
  • Tea Leaves: 25-50mg per cup

This means you’d need to eat about 10 servings of coffee ice cream to equal one cup of regular coffee.

Scoop Stack Challenge

How many scoops of Turkey Hill Coffee Ice Cream can you stack before it “melts”?

🍨

What Makes Turkey Hill Coffee Ice Cream Special

Turkey Hill uses high-quality Colombian coffee beans and coffee extract to create their signature coffee flavor profiles. The premium ice cream contains:

  • Real coffee extract from Colombian coffee beans
  • Whole milk for creamy texture
  • Natural flavors
  • Cane sugar (from sugar cane and sugar beets)
  • Basic ingredients like vanilla beans

The company’s PA facility uses milk from local cows, creating a thick liquid base that perfectly complements the coffee flavoring.

Comparing Coffee-Flavored Ice Creams

When ranking coffee ice cream flavors from popular brands, Turkey Hill’s Colombian Coffee consistently performs well. Other coffee ice creams and their approximate caffeine content include:

Ben & Jerry’s Coffee Ice Cream: 68mg per ½ cup
Häagen-Dazs Coffee: 58mg per ½ cup
Turkey Hill Colombian Coffee: 5-10mg per ½ cup
Van Leeuwen Coffee: 15-20mg per ½ cup
Jeni’s Ice Cream Coffee: 25mg per ½ cup

Compare Coffee Ice Cream Caffeine Content

Brand Caffeine (mg per ½ cup)
Ben & Jerry’s Coffee Ice Cream 68mg
Häagen-Dazs Coffee 58mg
Turkey Hill Colombian Coffee 5-10mg
Van Leeuwen Coffee 15-20mg
Jeni’s Ice Cream Coffee 25mg

Ingredients and Nutrition Facts

Turkey Hill’s commitment to quality shows in their ingredient list. The Colombian Coffee flavor contains:

Primary Ingredients:

  • Whole milk and skim milk from local cows
  • Cane sugar and brown sugar
  • Coffee extract
  • Natural flavors
  • Egg yolks for richness

Stabilizers and Additives:

  • Corn syrup as a natural thickening agent
  • Food grade stabilizers
  • Natural coloring

Allergen Information: Contains milk and eggs. The facility also processes tree nuts, so check food labels if you have major food allergens.

Storage and Shelf Life

Does Turkey Hill Coffee Ice Cream Have Caffeine – Scoops Of Coffee Ice Cream In A White Mug
Turkey Hill coffee ice cream does contain caffeine—about 5–10mg per ½ cup serving.

For the best experience with your container of ice cream:

  • Store in your home freezer at ideal temperature (0°F)
  • Keep for 3-4 weeks maximum
  • Don’t store at refrigerator temperature
  • The last scoop should taste as good as the first

Turkey Hill’s Coffee Ice Cream Varieties

Turkey Hill offers several coffee-inspired frozen desserts:

Colombian Coffee: The classic premium ice cream with real coffee
Double Dunker: Coffee ice cream with chocolate cookie pieces
Dutch Chocolate Iced Coffee: A drink option, not ice cream
Homemade Vanilla Iced Coffee: Another beverage variety

Each has different caffeine content, with the Colombian Coffee ice cream being the most caffeinated frozen dessert option.

When to Enjoy Coffee Ice Cream

Given the small amounts of caffeine, most people can enjoy Turkey Hill coffee ice cream any time without worrying about sleep disruption. However, if you’re particularly sensitive to caffeine or following medical advice about your daily diet, you might want to:

  • Limit evening consumption
  • Check with healthcare providers about caffeine as part of your daily value
  • Monitor how it affects your sleep patterns

The Bottom Line

Turkey Hill Colombian Coffee ice cream does contain caffeine—approximately 5-10mg per serving—but significantly less than other popular brands or actual coffee drinks. The caffeine comes from real Colombian coffee beans and coffee extract, giving it authentic coffee flavor profiles without the jolt of iced coffee.

Whether you’re shopping at grocery stores or visiting a local scoop shop, Turkey Hill’s coffee ice cream offers a delicious way to enjoy coffee flavor with minimal caffeine impact. It’s perfect for coffee lovers who want the taste without staying awake all night.

For those seeking caffeine-free alternatives, Turkey Hill offers plenty of other flavors like vanilla ice cream, chocolate ice creams with chocolate chips, and seasonal varieties that deliver the same creamy texture and premium quality without any caffeine content.

In conclusion, Does Turkey Hill Coffee Ice Cream Have Caffeine is a significant topic for dessert lovers.

Avatar Of Kelsey Todd
With over two decades in the coffee industry, Kelsey is a seasoned professional barista with roots in Seattle and Santa Barbara. Accredited by The Coffee Association of America and a member of The Baristas Guild, he combines practical expertise with a profound understanding of coffee's history and cultural significance. Kelsey tries his best to balance family time with blogging time and fails miserably.